After almost 24 hours to process just what the hell happened yesterday in Yerba Bueno I decided to give my two cents on the Apple iPad.
First, a small disclaimer. I own a MacBook, which took about the last two years to convince myself to purchase. I have a realistic look at Apple; I am by no means an “iFanboy” so, I will try to do my best in giving a fair and honest assessment. Oh, and by the way, I will mix in some of my opinion because that’s what I know the best.
The name iPad = overall fail
Ok. The name isn’t too bad, but if only after an hour of being announced something is being made fun of on Twitter and around the web (iTampon?) the name may not be the greatest. I felt the same way when the Wii was announced, so in time it may be OK. All connotations aside iPad sounds like iPod with a terrible Jersey accent. It wasn’t the greatest part of the God Tablet.
Input
As of right now we know of two ways to input on the iPad. One is the virtual keyboard. The second is the optional keyboard dock.
When I first saw the huge virtual keyboard enabled on a picture at Engadget, I thought to myself, “How in the hell am I going to use that?” The keyboard seems too big and typing with one finger at a time is not efficient at all. I see how one could place it on their lap and then type “regularly” on the virtual keyboard. To be honest I don’t see this as being comfortable at all.
The keyboard dock is cool, but why in portrait mode? I’d say that Steve SEVERALLY screwed this part up. What laptop or computer do you know of that has the screen sitting in portrait mode? None at all. Sometimes being different for the sake of being different isn’t “creative,” it is just trying to be different. What if I want to watch a quick video while docked? Now I have to watch it in a smaller size because I don’t have the width in portrait to view it.
Hardware
You can check out the specs here for the iPad. The screen seems large enough and from reports is “beautiful.” The unibody design is attractive. The Apple A4 chip is their own silicon and makes me wonder how far that will go (maybe into newer MacBooks). WiFi or 3G will be included. No camera.
To be honest I wasn’t shocked or too impressed by the hardware. It’s pretty and I am sure is made of high quality components. But really it’s just a large iPod Touch with 3G capabilities.
Content
The iPad’s iTunes integration looks very good. I am sure that the experience will be excellent. Not enough for me to drop the money on it though. I have a MacBook that can do the same media functions as the iPad, plus everything else I would ever need. Consuming media on this device is something that most consumers will probably do, I guess, but I think that having laptops that are around the same price will serve most consumers better.
eBooks
Here is where Apple could have made a huge difference; they could have thought of new innovative ways for students and professionals to use textbooks and manuals and created a new way of interacting with them. But they didn’t.
Did I miss something yesterday? Is there no way to annotate any type of notes on the iPad. A text book being displayed on a nice crystal-clear 9.7″ screen is useless to me if I can’t take any notes on it! Showing me a few “slick” animations when you are turning a page on your virtual book is really just a smoke screen blocking that they have missed the mark on the proper way to read and use digital books on a device. How sad.
I was assured that Apple was going to revolutionize the idea of eBooks. What they did was just follow the crowd which is not a normal stance for Jobs and Company.
Conclusion
The iPad is underwhelming. And because of that, there are a couple of larger points to make about mobile technology, the tech industry, and the tech media.
The tech media is crazy and it is truly out of control. I couldn’t believe how many bloggers and industry “experts” got most aspects of the iPad wrong. There were rumor after rumor after rumor on this damn tablet and most were incorrect. It is almost embarrassing. I understand that the media gives the people what they want to hear, but the impression that has been made to me is that the tech media just reports anything that they think may be true. It’s upsetting, and because of that I will try hard not to fall into that pit with all the rest.
Because of the push from the media I feel that Apple was almost forced to release this product. Jobs has been quoted saying that he didn’t think eBooks would succeed because no one reads anymore. I understand that he got the whole “no one wants video on their iPod” argument wrong, but after the presentation yesterday I got a sneaking suspicion that this device was forced from Apple. I don’t think that Jobs truly believes that it is as magical as he says it is. Therefore it’s hard for this cynical guy to get excited about it.
We’ll see where the iPad goes from here. As of right now though I’d say that the iPad will be for a select few gadget hungry, Apple loving folks that do not include myself.





